Current:Home > MarketsTexas man says facial recognition led to his false arrest, imprisonment, rape in jail -Infinite Edge Capital
Texas man says facial recognition led to his false arrest, imprisonment, rape in jail
Charles Langston View
Date:2025-04-10 02:58:15
An innocent Texas man was arrested, jailed for nearly two weeks and sexually assaulted just before his release, all because facial recognition software mistakenly identified him as the suspect of a store robbery, a new lawsuit alleges.
When two men robbed a Sunglass Hut in Houston on Jan. 22, 2022, 61-year-old Harvey Murphy Jr. was in a jail cell 2,000 miles away in Sacramento, California, according to the lawsuit obtained by USA TODAY on Wednesday.
Using low-quality surveillance footage of the robbery, artificial intelligence software at the Sunglass Hut falsely identified Murphy as a suspect, which led to a warrant for his arrest, according to the lawsuit filed last week in Harris County District Courts in Houston.
Later when Murphy returned to his home state of Texas, he was arrested, and a witness to the robbery identified him as a suspect. Murphy was held in jail for nearly two weeks until officials realized his alibi proved it was physically impossible for him to be responsible for the robbery.
But in the hours just before his release from jail, "he goes into the bathroom, where he gets followed by three men, beaten, sexually assaulted and raped," Murphy's attorney, Daniel Dutko, told USA TODAY on Wednesday.
Murphy was later released from jail and the charges against him were immediately dismissed.
Murphy is seeking $10 million from New York-based Macy's and French eyewear company EssilorLuxottica, which owns Sunglass Hut.
California arrest made for solid alibi
Murphy was on probation for a history of non-violent burglaries in the 1980s and '90s, according to Dutko. He was pulled over, arrested and taken to jail in California for failing to report his whereabouts, an obligation under his probation.
If it wasn't for Murphy being in jail the day of the Texas robbery, then he would not have the rock solid alibi that proved is innocence, Dutko said. He added that Murphy said if he had "just been at home watching TV and not had an alibi, (he) would be in prison right now."
"When Macy's and Sunglass Hut comes and says, 'We have your guy with 100% certainty,' that's the big issue," Dutko said.
Dutko said the results of the AI possibly influenced the witness who identified Murphy as one of the robbers and that he has information suggesting the store's loss-prevention team spoke to her before the line-up. Plus, eyewitness accuracy is known to be far from perfect.
Macy's declined to comment on the lawsuit. EssilorLuxottica hasn't responded to USA TODAY's requests for comment.
Murphy traumatized by time in Texas jail
Murphy has since seen a psychologist and psychiatrist to be treated for the trauma he endured in jail, Dutko said.
"He can't sleep at night," he said. "He can't stop thinking about it."
In jail, the men held a shank up to Murphy's neck and threatened to kill him if he ever told anyone. Dutko said.
USA TODAY does not typically name victims of sexual assault, but Dutko said it was important to his client to come forward so what happened to him doesn't happen again.
"'This can't keep happening. (If) I have to suffer the inconvenience of people knowing that it was me that got raped, but it stops this in the future, I'll do it,'" Murphy said, according to Dutko.
Lawsuit highlights dangers of facial recognition misuse
The lawsuit said that companies should not rely on AI technology to identify suspects.
"Any one of us could be improperly charged with a crime and jailed based on error-prone facial recognition software," the lawsuit says. "The companies that use this kind of software know it has a high rate of false positives, but they still use it to positively identify alleged criminals."
The lawsuit also alleges that EssilorLuxottica's facial recognition technology has a high accuracy rate only under ideal surveillance circumstances, including consistent lighting, positioning and no objects obstructing its view.
veryGood! (41)
Related
- Why Sean "Diddy" Combs Is Being Given a Laptop in Jail Amid Witness Intimidation Fears
- Stock market today: Asian stocks decline as China stimulus plan disappoints markets
- Man killed in Tuskegee University shooting in Alabama is identified. 16 others were hurt
- Sister Wives’ Janelle Brown Alleges Ex Kody Made False Claims About Family’s Finances
- As Trump Enters Office, a Ripe Oil and Gas Target Appears: An Alabama National Forest
- Jared Goff stats: Lions QB throws career-high 5 INTs in SNF win over Texans
- Miami Marlins hiring Los Angeles Dodgers first base coach Clayton McCullough as manager
- Arizona Supreme Court declines emergency request to extend ballot ‘curing’ deadline
- Trump invites nearly all federal workers to quit now, get paid through September
- Mississippi Valley State football player Ryan Quinney dies in car accident
Ranking
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Hi Hi!
- World War II veteran reflects on life as he turns 100
- Lane Kiffin puts heat on CFP bracket after Ole Miss pounds Georgia. So, who's left out?
- 'SNL' stars jokingly declare support for Trump, Dana Carvey plays Elon Musk
- Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
- See Leonardo DiCaprio's Transformation From '90s Heartthrob to Esteemed Oscar Winner
- Fire crews gain greater control over destructive Southern California wildfire
- These Yellowstone Gift Guide Picks Will Make You Feel Like You’re on the Dutton Ranch
Recommendation
South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
Don't Miss This Sweet Moment Between Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Dads at the Kansas City Chiefs Game
COINIXIAI Introduce
Will Trump curb transgender rights? After election, community prepares for worst
Retirement planning: 3 crucial moves everyone should make before 2025
Brian Kelly asks question we're all wondering after Alabama whips LSU, but how to answer?
Sister Wives’ Kody Brown Explains His Stance on His Daughter Gwendlyn Brown’s Sexuality
Fate of Netflix Series America’s Sweethearts: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Revealed